POLO CLUB

Dana Lezaj

2 years ago

Phenomenal food and drinks! Light, crispy calamari; large pieces of lobster in creamy lobster bisque; unique, yummy Sugar cookie martini; scrumptious Halibut with beurre blanc sauce. New decor was pretty. Waitress was attentive and proactive (only negative, they had her running to both sides of the dining room despite a different waitress at the table next to us - they need to map out the waitress stations better).

Mala Emera

5 months ago

I am writing to share our feedback following a recent visit to the Polo Club restaurant in Colts Neck. I am giving it a five-star rating for the exceptional food, ambience and service we received. The food was delicious, and the overall experience from arrival to departure was outstanding. In particular, I want to commend the manager, Nayab, who greatly enhanced our experience as first-time guests. We sincerely appreciated the attentive hospitality and frequent check-ins throughout our meal. We look forward to visiting again soon.

Victor Coppola

year ago

First time here. What an experience from the aesthetics, the service, the food, all top notch. My new favorite place. Outside of my cousin Ray (who's on a diet) everyone had great portions. Angela was our server who gets a special nod in taking care of cousin Ray. Very nice time.

Melissa

2 years ago

I highly recommend The Polo Club. My friends and I stopped by for drinks last night and they were amazing! Took a look at the food menu and if we didn’t already have reservations I would absolutely eat here. I will be back again for food AND drinks. The atmosphere is fantastic, the interior is absolutely stunning. Very clean inside and well kept. They have 2 bar areas with ample seating in the front area. The bar in the back is smaller but there is a large sitting area with tables and leather chairs to sit, relax and enjoy outstandingly made drinks. In the center of it all is a large open kitchen where you can watch the team prepare meals. If you’re lucky enough to be there on a Friday or Saturday night and Chris is making your drinks you are in for a treat. He takes drink mixing seriously. Drinks are well balanced and flavorful, no overstuffing of ice and sugary juice mixes here. The staff is extremely attentive. If something isn’t right, they’ll fix it. If you’re looking for something new to try they’re right there with recommendations. Kudos to Chris and Ryan at the back bar you both made the experience wonderful! Excellent job on the blue cheese stuffed olives Ryan, they were outstanding! My friends and I will definitely be back!!

Peter Marcin

3 years ago

We went to The Polo Club early on a Thursday evening. We were greeted warmly, and our coats were checked by the hostess. Being early, we were given our pick of where we wanted to sit. We chose the main dining room not far from the impressive open kitchen. The main bar was impressive, but we'll save that for another visit. Our waitress was very nice and attentive and took our drink orders quickly. I didn't have one but others in my party had Cosmopolitans which were excellent. Though they looked interesting, we skipped the small plate warm appetizers and split a Ceasar salad. It was a bit disappointing the dressing was not regular Ceasar, applied very lightly, and had a lemon base. Next time, we'd try another. For dinner, one party shared the 32 Oz Porterhouse, and we each chose 6oz filets. For sides, both fingerling and gratin potatoes were shared. Both choices of steak were excellent! They were cooked perfectly medium rare with a nice char on the outside and accompanied with a few slices of asparagus and a nice light steak sauce. Nothing but raves from all in our party for the dinner. Quite full, we skipped dessert and opted for a decaf coffee and a cappuccino. After dinner, the manager gave us a nice tour of all the seating areas, back bar, and wine cooler. Very impressive with lots of options for a different dining experience each time you visit. We'll be back.

njbettina

2 years ago

This is my 4th time here I believe. The restaurant is beautiful inside and the staff very inviting. We went to dinner on a Saturday night, 7 of us. We went to the bar first to have a drink while we waited for the others in our group. We arrived at 7pm and the bar which is fairly large was packed. Barely an empty seat. I felt sorry for the bartender as it seemed she was the only one working. There were two others behind the bar, I’m not sure what they were doing, not serving that’s for sure. Anyhow, once everyone arrived and drinks in hand the waitress showed us to our table. We sat in the back this time. Actually it was perfect. We ordered a few bottles of Brunella wine, apps and main meal. For the table we got 2 different salads, crispy cauliflower, tuna tartare, octopus and sweet potato fries. All delicious. Our main meals were rack of lamb, shrimp (which were huge) filet mignon, NY strip steak and a fish dish. The two strip steaks were supposed to be cooked medium but were a bit undercooked for their liking, but an easy fix, they brought it back to the kitchen and a few minutes later it seemed they were back on the table and all was good. The food was delicious, they didn’t rush us out. And I will definitely be back. It wasn’t cheap. It ran us about $150 pp but then again we had 3 bottles of wine

L. Scott Larsen

2 years ago

Outstanding dining experience. All of the dishes were well prepared, each carrying a unique taste. The calamari appetizer, not pictured, was well prepared with a reasonable portion. Perhaps the biggest surprise was the Togarashi crispy cauliflower. While not normally a fan of cauliflower, I have to admit this won me over. I could have had it for a meal. My wife raved about the land and see, and all of the meals were satisfying. If I would have one suggestion, it would be to add a bit more sauce to the linguine Bolognese. We were there on a Thursday night and there was plenty of parking. Service was excellent and the restaurant is nicely decorated. This is a remarkable facility for a special occasion.

Rachel Breton

year ago

Abby and Nicole were fantastic. Their food is reasonable and made well and well proportionate. The drinks were made well and the interior is super classy and warm. Definitely worth a visit. The petite filet minion 💕🔥. Second time visiting—overall, Friendly, clean, wholesome, and delicious

Jeffrey Karlin

9 months ago

Fabulous experience! I don’t think of coming here for whatever reason, maybe it’s the location. But I really should! The drinks were amazing as was the food! The ambience is incredible as well, perhaps better than any local restaurant. So warm and inviting. I really got a “homey” vibe while eating here. Had the tuna tartare, firecracker shrimp, filet mignon sliders, and lobster roll. All were great! Service was fabulous. Better than the Polo Club in Manhattan, imho. Check it out!

Donna DePalma

2 months ago

My husband and I have frequented The Polo Club in Holmdel on many occasions. The atmosphere is exquisite, the service is top notch!! The drinks are amazing. As you can see from our pictures the food is amazing!!! I highly recommend this restaurant!!! Thank you for your consistent service!